Greetings, baseball enthusiasts! In this article, we embark on a fascinating journey through the Cincinnati Reds’ history in the American League. The Reds, a beloved franchise with a rich tradition, have experienced both triumphs and setbacks during their time in the AL. Join us as we delve into the annals of the American League era, exploring the key moments, memorable players, and unforgettable storylines that have shaped the Reds’ legacy in this competitive league.
The Cincinnati Reds played in the American League from 1890, the league’s inaugural season, until 1900. The team had some success during this time, winning the league championship in 1899. However, the Reds’ most successful period came after they moved to the National League in 1901, where they have remained ever since.
Despite their relatively short time in the American League, the Reds left an enduring mark on the league. They were one of the original eight teams that played in the AL’s first season, and they were a competitive force throughout their tenure in the league. The Reds also produced some of the AL’s early stars, including Hall of Famers Paul Waner and Eppa Rixey.
Cincinnati Reds: American League Era
Why the Reds Joined the American League
From the mid-1950s to the early 1960s, the Cincinnati Reds faced a steady decline in attendance at their National League games. This was due in part to the growing popularity of television and the suburbs, as well as the team’s lack of success on the field. In 1960, the Reds drew just over 900,000 fans, their lowest total since 1945.
In an effort to boost attendance and revenue, the Reds explored the possibility of moving to the American League. The American League had been expanding into new markets in recent years, and the Reds believed that they could tap into a new fan base by joining the league. Additionally, the American League was generally considered to be a more competitive league than the National League, and the Reds felt that they would have a better chance of success against American League teams.
In 1961, the Reds and four other National League teams applied to join the American League. The American League ultimately approved the expansion application of only the Houston Colt .45s and the New York Mets, but the Reds remained interested in joining the league. In 1963, the Reds and the Boston Braves (who would later move to Atlanta) reapplied to join the American League, and this time they were both approved.
The Reds joined the American League in 1969, and they remained in the league until 1994. During their time in the American League, the Reds won two World Series championships (1975 and 1976) and six division titles. They also had several individual stars, including Johnny Bench, Joe Morgan, and Pete Rose.
Notable Moments in the American League
World Series Appearances
The Cincinnati Reds made three appearances in the World Series during their time in the American League:
1919
The Reds lost to the Chicago White Sox in the 1919 World Series, four games to three. The series was marred by controversy, as eight White Sox players were later accused of intentionally losing games in exchange for money. The scandal led to the banning of the eight players from baseball for life.
1939
The Reds lost to the New York Yankees in the 1939 World Series, four games to none. The Yankees were led by Joe DiMaggio, who hit safely in all four games of the series. The Reds were led by Paul Derringer, who pitched a complete game in Game 2 but took the loss.
1940
The Reds lost to the Detroit Tigers in the 1940 World Series, four games to three. The Tigers were led by Hank Greenberg, who hit three home runs in the series. The Reds were led by Bucky Walters, who pitched a complete game in Game 3 but took the loss.
Other Notable Moments
In addition to their three World Series appearances, the Reds also had several other notable moments during their time in the American League:
- In 1938, the Reds won the American League pennant with a record of 97-57. This was the first time the Reds had won a pennant since 1919.
- In 1944, the Reds won the American League pennant with a record of 89-65. This was the second time the Reds had won a pennant since 1919.
- In 1954, the Reds finished with a record of 64-90. This was the worst record in the American League that season.
- In 1956, the Reds moved to the National League.
Key Players in the American League
The Cincinnati Reds, despite never playing in the American League, have had several key players make their mark in that league.
Paul Derringer
Paul Derringer, a star pitcher for the Cincinnati Reds in the 1930s, had a brief but impactful stint in the American League with the Chicago White Sox. In 1930, Derringer won the American League MVP award after leading the league in wins (26), strikeouts (200), and ERA (3.05). He became the first player in major league history to win the Triple Crown for pitching, a feat that would not be repeated until Jim Palmer in 1975. Derringer’s dominance on the mound helped the White Sox capture the American League pennant that year, propelling them to the World Series. However, they ultimately fell short in the championship series to the Philadelphia Athletics.
Derringer’s success in the American League continued in 1931 as he once again led the league in wins (23) and strikeouts (174). He played a pivotal role in the White Sox’s second consecutive American League pennant, but this time they faced the St. Louis Cardinals in the World Series. Despite Derringer’s valiant efforts, the Cardinals emerged victorious in a thrilling seven-game series.
Derringer’s time with the White Sox came to an end in 1933 when he was traded back to the Cincinnati Reds. He continued to pitch at a high level for several more seasons, cementing his legacy as one of the most dominant pitchers of his era.
Derringer’s impressive accolades extend beyond his 1930 MVP award and Triple Crown victory. He was a four-time All-Star selection and finished his career with a remarkable 206 wins, 2,031 strikeouts, and a 3.49 ERA. His contributions to the game of baseball were recognized when he was inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 1962.
Reasons for Leaving the American League
The decision for the Reds to leave the American League and return to the National League was a complex one, influenced by a multitude of factors. Here are the key reasons behind their departure:
Low Attendance in Cincinnati:
One of the primary reasons for the Reds’ departure from the American League was dwindling attendance in Cincinnati. During their time in the league, the Reds struggled to draw fans to their games, with attendance figures consistently falling below those of established AL teams. This decline in attendance had a significant financial impact on the team, as ticket sales were a crucial source of revenue.
Difficulty Competing with Established AL Teams:
Another factor that contributed to the Reds’ decision to leave the American League was the difficulty they faced in competing with the league’s established powerhouses. Teams such as the New York Yankees, Boston Red Sox, and Chicago White Sox had dominant rosters and long-standing legacies, making it challenging for the Reds to find success. The Reds repeatedly finished near the bottom of the AL standings, further contributing to the frustration of fans and the management.
Desire to Return to the Team’s Original League:
Beyond the financial and competitive struggles, there was also a sentimental attachment to the National League among the Reds organization and its supporters. The Reds had been a charter member of the National League when it was founded in 1876 and had played there for over 50 years before joining the American League. The team’s history and identity were deeply intertwined with the National League, and many fans and players alike felt a sense of belonging to that league.
Additional Factors:
In addition to the reasons mentioned above, several other factors also contributed to the Reds’ departure from the American League. These included:
-
Differences in playing styles between the two leagues. The National League was known for its focus on pitching and defense, while the American League prioritized hitting and offense. The Reds felt that their strengths aligned more closely with the National League style of play.
-
Familiarity with opponents. The Reds had long-standing rivalries with teams in the National League, particularly the St. Louis Browns and the Chicago Cubs. The opportunity to renew these rivalries was an appealing factor for both the team and its fans.
-
Financial incentives. The National League offered the Reds a more favorable financial package, including a larger share of television revenue. This incentive played a significant role in the team’s ultimate decision.
Ultimately, the combination of financial struggles, competitive challenges, and sentimental attachment to the National League led the Reds to seek a return to their original league. The move proved to be a successful one, as the Reds quickly reestablished themselves as a competitive force in the National League and won their first pennant since 1919 in 1939.
Legacy of the American League Era
Contributions to Baseball History
Growth of the Cincinnati Reds Fanbase
The Reds’ entry into the American League exposed them to a wider national audience, significantly increasing their fanbase. Previously, the team had primarily played in the National League, which had a smaller reach than the American League. As a result, the Reds gained new fans from across the United States, solidifying their status as one of the most popular teams in baseball.
Competitive Environment for Reds Players
Playing in the American League provided a different competitive landscape for the Reds. The American League was generally considered to be a stronger league than the National League, and the Reds faced stiffer competition in their daily matchups. This environment helped to elevate the performance of Reds players, as they were constantly challenged by some of the best competition in the sport. As a result, many Reds players achieved personal milestones and career highs during their time in the American League.
Influence on Baseball Development
The Reds’ time in the American League also contributed to the development of baseball as a national pastime. The team’s success and popularity helped to promote the sport and inspire young boys and girls to play baseball. Additionally, the Reds’ presence in the American League exposed baseball to new regions and helped to increase its fan base. The team’s impact on the growth of baseball cannot be understated, and it remains a significant chapter in the history of the sport.
Notable Players and Moments
The Reds’ American League era was marked by several notable players and moments that left a lasting impact on the team and the sport itself. One of the most iconic players from this era was Paul Derringer, a pitcher who won 161 games for the Reds in the American League, including 23 wins in 1939. He was a key member of the Reds’ pitching staff and helped lead the team to the 1939 and 1940 World Series.
Another notable player from the American League era was Ernie Lombardi, a catcher who was considered one of the best defensive catchers in baseball history. He caught over 2,000 games for the Reds and was known for his strong arm and quick reflexes. Lombardi was a 7-time All-Star selection and was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1986.
In addition to individual accomplishments, the Reds also achieved some impressive team milestones during their American League tenure. In 1939, the team won 97 games and captured the American League pennant. This was the team’s first pennant since 1919 and was a significant achievement for a team that had struggled in the years leading up to World War II. The Reds also reached the World Series in 1940, where they lost to the Detroit Tigers in seven games.
Transition Back to the National League
Despite their success in the American League, the Reds ultimately decided to return to the National League in 1961. This decision was motivated by several factors, including a desire to be closer to their traditional rivals and a belief that the National League was a better fit for their style of play. The Reds’ return to the National League marked the end of their American League era, but the team’s contributions to baseball history during that time remain significant.
Current Impact of the American League Era: A Deeper Dive
Historical Perspective
The Cincinnati Reds’ tenure in the American League from 1890 to 1900 serves as a poignant chapter in the franchise’s rich history. It offers valuable insights into the team’s evolution and the arduous journey it has undertaken to become the storied club it is today. By revisiting this era, fans can connect with the team’s past achievements, understand its struggles, and appreciate the resilience that has defined the Reds’ legacy.
Furthermore, this historical perspective helps maintain a strong fan base by providing a sense of continuity and reminding supporters of the team’s long-standing presence in the city of Cincinnati. It fosters a sense of pride and belonging, ensuring that the Reds remain a beloved institution in the Queen City’s sporting landscape.
Economic Impact on the Reds Franchise
The Reds’ presence in the American League had a significant economic impact on the franchise. As one of the eight founding members of the league, the Reds benefited from the increased popularity and financial stability that came with being a part of a major professional sports organization. The team’s inclusion in the American League also led to increased ticket sales, merchandise sales, and television revenue, providing a financial foundation for the Reds to invest in talented players and build a competitive team.
Contribution to the Development of Baseball
The Cincinnati Reds played a vital role in the development of baseball during their American League era. They introduced several innovations to the game, including the use of a designated hitter, the adoption of the seven-inning doubleheader, and the establishment of a formal farm system. These innovations helped shape the modern game of baseball and continue to be used today, providing a lasting legacy for the Reds’ contributions to the sport.
Legacy in the Queen City
The Cincinnati Reds’ American League legacy continues to shape the team’s identity and its connection to the Queen City. The team’s rich history is celebrated throughout the city, with landmarks such as Crosley Field and the Reds Hall of Fame serving as reminders of the team’s past. The Reds’ enduring presence in Cincinnati has fostered a passionate fan base that supports the team through both triumphs and setbacks, making the Reds an integral part of the city’s cultural fabric.
Impact on the National League
After leaving the American League in 1900, the Cincinnati Reds joined the National League, where they have remained ever since. The Reds’ experience in the American League gave them a valuable competitive edge over their National League rivals, as they were familiar with the American League’s rules, strategies, and player talent. This advantage helped the Reds become a dominant force in the National League, winning five World Series championships and establishing themselves as one of the most successful franchises in baseball history.
Conclusion
The Cincinnati Reds’ American League era is a multifaceted chapter in the team’s history that has had a profound impact on the franchise, the city of Cincinnati, and the development of baseball as a whole. By providing a historical perspective, highlighting its economic impact, recognizing its contribution to baseball’s evolution, exploring its legacy in the Queen City, and examining its influence on the National League, we gain a deeper appreciation for the enduring legacy of the Cincinnati Reds.